2001年の第39号のときに年2号体制（原則として、7月と1月に発行）に改められました。
2005年の第47巻から現在の名称に変更され、今までの号を巻に読み替えると同時に、巻の下に号を新設しました。
なお、1989年の第27巻から公募論文の査読制を導入しました。
投稿規程
執筆要網
『経済学史研究』最新号
J-STAGEから過去の論文にアクセスできます。
『経済学史研究』『経済学史学会年報』
65巻2号（2024年1月）
65巻1号（2023年7月）
64巻2号（2023年1月）
64巻1号（2022年7月）
63巻2号（2022年1月）
63巻1号（2021年7月）
62巻2号（2021年1月）
62巻1号（2020年10月）
61巻2号（2020年1月）
61巻1号（2019年7月）
60巻2号（2019年1月）
60巻1号（2018年7月）
59巻2号（2018年1月）
59巻1号（2017年7月）
58巻2号（2017年1月）
58巻1号（2016年7月）
［工事中］
［工事中］
［工事中］
［工事中］
［工事中］
『経済学史研究』59巻2号（2018年1月）目次
論文
-
Series: War and Economics〈2〉
Shigeyoshi Senga, War among the Sovereign States and the Generation of Economics1-18
-
War among the Sovereign States
and the Generation of EconomicsShigeyoshi Senga
Abstract:
The focus of this paper is the wars in Europe from the middle of the seventeenth century to
the early nineteenth century and their relationship with contemporary economics1（ limited to
England and Scotland）. As for the relationship between war and economy, there has been the
accepted view that war may arise due to particular economic interests. While it is true that
early mercantilists saw foreign trade and war as inseparable, major economists in this period
did not find a cause for war in economy. Economists wrestled with the practicalities of financing
war, such as the tax reform, but as public loans were enlarged for the expenditure of
war, warned against mercantilist wars and the bankruptcy of the state. Smith and Tucker had
different opinions about the independence of the American colonies, and Malthus and Ricardo
disputed the causes of the recession that followed the Napoleonic Wars. The economists
of this era, although considering war as a political matter, continued to look for ways to evade
war. The issue of war as a struggle for supremacy between states was expected to be replaced
by efforts to strengthen commercial and industrial competitiveness in the free trade market.
JEL classification numbers: B 11, B 12, N 45.参考文献:
Clausewitz, C［. 1832］ 1993. On War, ed. and trans. by M. Howard and P. Paret. Everyman’s
Library 121. London: Princeton University Press.
Davenant, C［. 1695］ 1967. An Essay upon Ways and Means of Supplying the War. In The Political
and Commercial Works of that Celebrated Writer Charles D’Avenant, Vol. I（, rpt.）,
ed. by C. Whitworth（ coll. and revised）. Farnborough: Gregg Press.
Defoe, D［. 1728］ 1967. A Plan of the English Commerce, 2nd ed., 1730（. rpt.） New York: A.
M. Kelley.
Hont, I. 2005. Jealousy of Trade: International Competition and the Nation-State in Histori-
cal Perspective. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.
–. 2015. Politics in Commercial Society. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University
Press.
Hume, D.［ 1752］ 1882. Political Discourses. In The Philosophical Works of David Hume.
Vol. III. Ed. by T. H. Green and T. H. Grose（. rpt.） London: Scientia Verlag Aalen.
Lefebvre, H. ［1974］ 1991. The Production of Space. English translation by D. Nicholson-
Smith. Oxford: Blackwell.
Malthus, R.［ 1820］ 1986. Principles of Political Economy. 2nd ed., 1836. In The Works of
Thomas Robert Malthus. Vol. VI（ rpt.）, ed. by E. A. Wright and D. Souden. London: William
Pickering.
Milgate, M. and S. C. Stimson. 1991. Ricardian Politics. Princeton: Princeton University
Press.
Mun, T［. 1664（1620s）］ 1910. England’s Treasure by Forraign Trade（. rpt.） New York: Macmillan.
Petty, W［. 1662］ 1986. A Treatise of Taxes & Contributions. In The Economic Writings of Sir
William Petty. Vol. I（ rpt.）, ed. by H. C. Hull. Fairfield: A. M. Kelley.
–［. 1691］ 1986. Verbum Sapienti. In Hull, ed., op. cit., Vol. I.
Phillipson, N. 2010. Adam Smith: An Enlightened Life. New Haven and London: Yale University
Press.
Pocock, J. A. 1975. The Machiavellian Moment: Florentine Political Thought and the Atlantic
Republican Tradition. Princeton and London: Princeton University Press.
–. 1985. Virtue, Commerce, and History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ricardo, D. 1951-1973. The Works and Correspondence of David Ricardo. vols. I-XI, ed. by P.
Sraffa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Robbins, L. 1939. The Economic Cause of War. London: Jonathan Cape.
–. 1957. The Economic Problem in Pease and War; Some Reflections on Objectives and
Mechanism. London: Macmillan.
Ross, I. S., 1995. The Life of Adam Smith. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Shumpeter, J. A. 1951. Imperialism and Social Class. Trans. by Heinz Norden, ed. by and
with an intro. by Paul M. Sweezy. New York: A. M. Kelly.
–. 1954. History of Economic Analysis. Ed. from manuscript by Elizabeth Boody Schumpeter.
New York: Oxford University Press.
Smith, A.［ 1776］ 1976. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations. In
The Glasgow Edition of the Works and Correspondence of Adam Smith. vols. 1-2. Oxford:
Clarendon Press.
Steuart, J［. 1767］ 1995. An Inquiry into the Principles of Political Oeconomy. In The Works,
Political, Metaphysical, and Chronological, of the late Sir James Stuart of Coltness,
Bart. &c. vols. 1-4（. rpt.） London: Routledge.
Thomas, P. J. 1926. Mercantilism and the East India Trade. London: Frank Cass.
Tucker, J［. 1774］ 1931. Four Tracts, together with Two Sermons, on Political and Commercial
Subjects. In Josiah Tucker: A Selection from his Economic and Political Writings.
New York: Columbia University Press.
Wilson, C.［ 1957］ 1978. Profit and Power; A Study of England and The Dutch Wars. 2nd
printing. The-Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.
-
Series: War and Economics〈3〉
Tsutomu Hashimoto, A Fundamental Economic Thought Problem on Peace and War since the Cold War: A Critical Appraisal of E. Schumacher, J. Galbraith, and K. Boulding19-34
-
A Fundamental Economic Thought Problem
on Peace and War since the Cold War:
A Critical Appraisal of E. Schumacher, J. Galbraith,
and K. BouldingTsutomu Hashimoto
Abstract:
This paper raises a fundamental question and offers an original framework on war and peace
arguments based on primarily examining contributions in the field of war and economic
thought after World War II. Among the prominent figures in this field, I select three thinkers
in the field of economic thought, E. Schumacher, J. Galbraith, and K. Boulding, who presented
their own systematic visions of a peaceful society. The fundamental question on war and
peace raised here is, how we receive the principles of bios and eros, and of prosperity, from
an ideally peaceful situation, wherein the nature of peace is defined as “the negation of bios”
（i.e., the principle of death）. In order to examine this question, I propose an original framework
and define the concepts of war and peace using categories of conflict and violence.
In light of this fundamental question, in this paper, I reveal the contributions of the three
thinkers to our understanding of creating a peaceful world. First, I present the background
and explain the reasons for selecting these three figures. Second, I present the fundamental
question and my theoretical framework to explore the responses of the three thinkers to the
question. Finally, I clarify their responses and present an overview of their contributions towards
a peaceful society.
JEL classification numbers: B 20, B 52, P 40.参考文献:
Andics, Hellmut. 1969. Rule of Terror: Russia under Lenin and Stalin, trans. by Alexander
Lieven. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.
Arrow, Kenneth. 1994. “International Peace-keeping Forces: Economics and Politics.” In The
Economics of International Security: Essays in Honour of Jan Tinbergen, ed. by Manas
Chatterji, Henk Jager, and Annemarie Rima. London: St. Martin’s Press.
Boulding, Kenneth E. 1941. Economic Analysis. New York: Harper.
–. 1942. A Peace Study Outline: The Practice of the Love of God. Philadelphia Yearly
Meeting Book Committee.
–. 1945. The Economics of Peace. New York: Prentice Hall.
–. 1962. Conflict and Defense: A General Theory. New York: Harper and Bros.
–. 1968. Beyond Economics: Essays on Society, Religion, and Ethics. Ann Arbor, Michigan:
University of Michigan Press.
–. 1973. The Economy of Love and Fear: A Preface to Grants Economics. Belmont, California:
Wadsworth Publishing.
–. 1975. International Systems: Peace, Conflict Resolution, and Politics. In Collected Papers:
Kenneth E. Boulding, Volume 5, ed. by Larry D. Singell. Boulder, Colorado: Colorado
Associated University Press.
–. 1978 a. Stable Peace. Austin, Texas: University of Texas Press.
–. 1978 b. Ecodynamics: A New Theory of Societal Evolution. Beverly Hills, California:
Sage Publications.
–. 1985. Toward the Twenty-first Century: Political Economy, Social Systems, and World
Peace. In Collected Papers: Kenneth E. Boulding, Volume 6, ed. by Larry D. Singell.
Boulder, Colorado: Colorado Associated University Press.
–. ed. 1970. Peace and the War Industry. Chicago, Illinois: Aldine Publishing.
Boulding, Kenneth E. and Emile Benoit, eds. 1963. Disarmament and the Economy. New
York: Harper and Row.
Boulding, Kenneth E. and Tapan Mukerjee, eds. 1972. Economic Imperialism: A Book of
Readings. Ann Arbor, Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
Clausewitz, Carl von. 1976. Vom Kriege: hinterlassenes Werk, als Volksausgabe herausgegeben
von A. W. Bode. Leipzig: H. Schaufuß （1832）, On War, ed. and trans. by Michael
Howard and Peter Paret. New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Freud, Sigmund. 1932. “Warum Krieg,” in Gesammelte Werke: Chronologisch Geordnet Bd.
16. Werke aus den Jahren 1932-1939（ 1961）.
Galbraith, John Kenneth. 1958. Affluent Society. Boston, Massachusetts: Riverside Press.
–. 1967 a. The New Industrial State. Boston, Massachusetts: Houghton Mifflin.
–. 1967 b. How to Get out of Vietnam: A Workable Solution to the Worst Problem of Our
Time. New York: New American Library.
–. 1969. How to Control the Military. New York: New American Library.
–. 1971. A Contemporary Guide to Economics Peace and Laughter, essays ed. by Andrea
D. Williams. New York: New American Library.
–. 1979. Annals of an Abiding Liberal, ed. by Andrea D. Williams. Boston, Massachusetts:
Houghton Mifflin.
–. 1981. A Life in Our Times: Memoirs. New York: Ballantine Books.
–. 1992. The Culture of Contentment. Boston, Massachusetts: Houghton Mifflin.
–. 1999. The Economics of Compassion, Japanese edition. Tachibana Publishing.
Hume, David.［ 1777］ 1987. Essays, Moral, Political, and Literary, ed. by Eugene F. Miller.
Indianapolis, Indiana: Liberty Fund.
The Institute for Economics & Peace. 2011. “Economic Consequences of War on the U.S.
Economy,” from http://www.thereformedbroker.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/Eco
nomic-Consequences-of-War.pdf（ accessed 2016/06/18）.
Klein, Lawrence R., Fu-chen Lo and Warwick J. McKibbin, eds. 1995. Arms Reduction: Economic
Implications in the Post-Cold War Era. Tokyo: United Nations University Press.
Leontief, Wassily and Faye Duchin. 1983. Military Spending: Facts and Figures, Worldwide
Implications, and Future Outlook. New York: Oxford University Press.
McDonald, Patrick J. 2009. The Invisible Hand of Peace. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
Parker, Richard. 2005. John Kenneth Galbraith: His Life, His Politics, His Economics. Chicago,
Illinois: University of Chicago Press.
Robertson, James. 2011. Transforming Economic Life: A Millennial Challenge, Schumacher
briefing, No. 1, Green Books for the Schumacher Society.
Robinson, J. 1972. The Second Crisis of Economic Theory. American Economic Review 62
（1/2）: 1-10.
Schelling, Thomas. 1960. The Strategy of Conflict. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University
Press.
Schumacher, Ernst Friedrich. 1973. Small Is Beautiful: A Study of Economics as if People
Mattered. New York: Harper and Row.
–. 1979. Good Work. New York: Harper and Row.
–. 1997. This I Believe and Other Essays. Totnes: Green Books.
Scott, Robert. 2015. Kenneth Boulding: A Voice Crying in the Wilderness. Basingstoke: Palgrave
Macmillan.
Smith, Adam［. 1776］ 1976. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations.
In The Glasgow Edition of the Works and Correspondence of Adam Smith, Vols. 2a-2b,
ed. by R. H. Campbell and A. S. Skinner. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Wood, Barbara. 1985. Alias Papa: A Life of Fritz Schumacher. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
-
仲北浦淳基 D. H. ロバートソンの「実物」的経済変動論― 『産業変動の研究』における「努力」概念―
35-55
-
D. H. Robertson’s ‘Real’ Theory of Economic Fluctuation:
‘Effort’ Concept in his Study of Industrial Fluctuation（ 1915）Junki Nakakitaura
Abstract:
This paper aims to explore the two essential factors of Dennis Holme Robertson’s theory of
economic fluctuation. Of the two, his ‘effort’ concept is important as the core of his real theory,
and his ‘industry’ concept is methodologically significant. These concepts in his first book,
A Study of Industrial Fluctuation, offer clarity regarding his economic view and a method of
macroeconomic analysis.
The ‘effort’ concept implicates the behavioural decision of individuals（ micro-analysis）.
All humans exert ‘effort’ for getting ‘satisfaction’ to maximise their ‘net satisfaction,’ that is,
the difference between utility and disutility. In other words, any behavioural decisions are
based upon the ‘effort’ of individuals. The ‘industry’ concept is provisionally considered as a
coordinated group of individuals. Therefore, the behavioural decision of ‘industry’ is assumed
to be the same as that of individuals, which is based on an individual’s ‘effort.’ With these two
concepts, Robertson gradually extended his analysis from an individual （micro-analysis） to
industries and industry in general（ macro-analysis）. This is the very macro analytical method
of Robertsonian economics.
The ‘effort’ concept is also the core of overall Robertsonian economics; for his subsequent
major theories, ‘capitalism’s golden rule’ and ‘lacking,’ also are grounded in his ‘effort’
concept. Any factors, such as the labour-capital conflict or monetary disturbance, can cause
fluctuations. For Robertson, however, ‘effort’ is the only ‘real’ measure and should be assigned
the highest weight as the essential factor.
Such a re-evaluation of Robertson’s ‘real’ theory is expected to furnish some hints with
regards to certain outstanding issues of Robertsonian economics: （1） the ultimate cause of
discord with Keynes,（ 2） inheritances from Marshall, and（ 3） the unified understanding of
the ‘real’ and ‘monetary’ theories in Robertson’s works.
JEL classification numbers: B 13, E 32.参考文献:
Anyadike-Danes, M. K. 1985. Dennis Robertson and Keynes’s General Theory. In Keynes and His Contemporaries: The
Sixth and Centennial Keynes Seminar held at the University of Kent at Canterbury, 1983, ed. by G. C. Harcout. London:
Macmillan, 105―23.
Boianovsky, M. 2014. Robertson and the Cambridge Approach to Utility and Welfare. Cambridge Journal of Economics
38（ 4）: 1―36.
Bridel, P. 1987. Cambridge Monetary Thought: The Development of Saving-Investment Analysis from Marshall to
Keynes. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
―. 2017. Robertson’s Industrial Fluctuation （1915）: An Early Real Business Cycle-Like Approach. Journal of the
History of Economic Thought 39（ 1）: 35―46
Dennison, S. R. 1992. Preface. In Essays on Robertsonian Economics, ed. by J. R. Presley. London: Macmillan, viii-xi.
Fletcher, G. A. 2000. Understanding Dennis Robertson: The Man and His Work. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
―. 2008. Dennis Robertson. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. 下平裕之訳『デニス・ロバートソン』勁草書房，
2015.
Goodhart, C. A. E. 1992. Dennis Robertson and the Real Business Cycle. In Essays on Robertsonian Economics, ed. by J.
R. Presley. London: St. Martin’s Press, 8―34.
Haberler, G.［ 1939］ 1958. Prosperity and Depression: A Theoretical Analysis of Cyclical Movements, 4th ed. London:
George Allen and Unwin. 松本達治・加藤寛孝・山本英太郎他訳『景気変動論（上），（下）』東洋経済新報
社，1966.
Jevons, W. S［. 1871］ 1911. The Theory of Political Economy, 4th ed. London: Macmillan. 小泉信三・寺尾琢磨訳『経
済学の理論』日本経済評論社，1981.
Komine, A. 2014. Keynes and His Contemporaries: Tradition and Enterprise in the Cambridge School of Economics.
London: Routledge, 17―27.
Marshall, A.［ 1890］ 1961. Principles of Economics, 9th ed. by C. W. Guillebaud. London: Macmillan. 馬場啓之助訳
『経済学原理』東洋経済新報社，1965―1967.
Presley, J. R. 1979. Robertsonian Economics: An Examination of the Work of Sir D. H. Robertson on Industrial Fluctuation.
London: Macmillan.
―. 1981. D. H. Robertson, 1890―1963. In Pioneers of Modern Economics in Britain, ed. by D. P. O’Brien and J. R.
Presley. London: Macmillan, 175―202. 西岡幹雄訳「D. H. ロバートソン」，井上琢智・上宮正一郎・八木紀
一郎他訳『近代経済学の開拓者』所収，昭和堂，185―215, 1986.
Robertson, D. H. 1914. Michel Tougan-Baranowsky, Les Crisis Industrielles en Angletere, and Albert Aftalion, Les Crisis
Periodiques Surproduction. Economic Journal 24（ 93）: 81―89.
―. 1915. A Study of Industrial Fluctuation: An Enquiry into the Character and Causes of the So-called Cyclical
Movements of Trade. London: P. S. King. Reprinted with a new introduction. London: London School of Economics
and Political Science, 1948［. SIF］
―. 1922. Money. London: Nisbet, University Press. 安井琢磨・熊谷尚夫訳『貨幣』岩波書店，1956.
―. 1923. The Control of Industry. London: Nisbet, University Press. 井上貞蔵・大森英治郎訳『産業統制論』同
文館，1930.
―. 1926. Banking Policy and the Price Level: An Essays in the Theory of the Trade Cycle. London: P. S. King. 高田
博訳『銀行政策と価格水準―景気循環理論に関する一試論』巌松堂書店，1955.
―. 1957. Lectures on Economic Principles, Vol. 1. London: Staple Press. 森川太郎・高本昇訳『経済原論講義』（第
I 巻），東洋経済新報社，1960.
Shimodaira, H. 2011. Dennis Robertson’s The Control of Industry. In Marshall, Marshallians and Industrial Economics,
ed. by T. Raffaelli, T. Nishizawa, and S. Cook. London: Taylor and Francis, 213―27.
Spencer, D. A. 2005. A Question of Incentive? Lionel Robbins and Dennis H. Robertson on the Nature and Determinants
of the Supply of Labour. European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 12（ 2）: 261―78.
青山秀夫．1942.「 実物的波及過程の弾性分析―ピグウ＝ロバアトソンの景気理論における弾性概念の応用に
ついて」『經濟論叢』（京都大学）55（ 1）: 68―83.
伊藤史朗．1951「. ロバートソンの景気理論」『経済論叢』（京都大学）68（ 1―3）: 25―63.
伊藤宣広．2007 a.「 産業変動論におけるピグーとロバートソン」『立教経済学研究』（立教大学）60（ 3）: 69―
92.
―. 2007 b『. ケンブリッジ学派のマクロ経済分析―マーシャル・ピグー・ロバートソン』ミネルヴァ書房．
小原英隆．1997.「 デニス・ロバートソンの実物的景気循環と財政・金融政策―現代リアルビジネスサイクル
理論とケインズ『貨幣論』との関係」『社会科学研究』（東京大学社会科学研究所）49（ 1）: 75―134.
―. 1998.「 ファイナンス制約モデルの先駆としてのロバートソンの貨幣動学理論―ケインズとは別方向の
『進化』」『社会科学研究』（東京大学社会科学研究所）49（ 4）: 91―245.
河野良太．2003「. ロバートソンの貯蓄―投資分析」『経済情報学研究』（姫路獨協大学）28:1―92.
―. 2009「. 伊藤宣広『ケンブリッジ学派のマクロ経済分析―マーシャル・ピグー・ロバートソン』ミネルヴァ
書房，2007, iv+255 頁」『経済学史研究』50（ 2）: 103―04.
小峯 敦．1992「. ロバートソンの個人録」『一橋研究』（一橋大学）17（ 1）: 99―113.
下平裕之．1995「. D. H. ロバートソンの経済変動理論―初期の発展とケインズの影響」『一橋研究』（一橋大学）
19（ 4）: 29―46.
―. 1996.「 デニス・ロバートソン『産業変動の研究』の歴史的意義」『一橋論叢』（一橋大学）116（ 6）: 1069―
82.
―. 2003「. デニス・ロバートソン研究の展開―G. フレッチャーのロバートソン論を中心に」『山形大学紀要』
（山形大学）34（ 1）: 141―61.
仲北浦淳基．2016 a.「 ロバートソンにおけるリスクとコントロールの経済学―『産業変動の研究』と『産業
のコントロール』との関連性の考察」『経済学論叢』（同志社大学）68（ 1）: 141―70.
―. 2016 b「. ロバートソンの最初期の経済学研究と『努力』概念」『経済学論叢』（同志社大学）68（ 2）: 249―
75.
―. 2017 a.「 ロバートソンの実物理論における消費・投資・貯蓄―『努力』概念から『ラッキング』概念へ
の展開」『経済学論叢』（同志社大学）69（ 1）: 183―208.
―. 2017 b「. ロバートソンにおける実業家と銀行家」『経済学論叢』（同志社大学）69（ 2）: 1―20.
―. 2017 c.「 ロバートソンにおけるケンブリッジの伝統と革新―『努力』概念の系譜と新たな意義」『経済
学論叢』（同志社大学）69（ 3）: 89―115.
服部容教．1998.「 D. H. ロバートソンは実物景気循環理論の先駆者か？」『大阪市立大学証券研究年報』（ 13）:
17―28.
菱山 泉．1965『. 近代経済学の歴史―マーシャル，ピグー，ロバートソン，ケインズ』有信堂．
丸山 徹．2016「. 書評『デニス・ロバートソン』評者・丸山徹」『週刊エコノミスト』94（ 14）: 64―65.
-
56-74
-
Economic Chivalry and Laissez-faire:
A Study in the Tradition of Marshall, Pigou, Edgeworth, and KeynesNaoki Matsuyama
Abstract:
The aim of this study is to shed light on the unknown tradition of Marshall’s ethical notion of
‘economic chivalry,’ then inherited by A. C. Pigou, F. Y. Edgeworth, and J. M. Keynes. At the
beginning, this work argues that while Marshall actually regretted not being able to indicate
the practical aspects of economic chivalry in his speech in 1907, the point was later discussed
by other contemporary economists. Specifically, in his public lecture, Pigou suggested that all
employers should be guided by a spirit of economic chivalry, in order to built the facilities
where young workers could have an opportunity to train physical and mental abilities. Then,
Edgeworth regarded economic chivalry as a philosophical foundation for his economic welfare
analysis, in which female workers should be treated equally to male ones, with the wage
level determined only by productivity, not by gender differences. It is for this reason that he
also pointed out the necessity of a subsidy to families. Finally, Keynes believed that, in the
interwar period, the British economy could not recover only through the effort of chivalrous
businessmen, who attempted to harmonise public interest and personal gain. The reason is
that he negatively considered chivalrous businessmen, defining them a ‘tarnished idol’ in business
practice at the time. Nevertheless, Keynes also argued the importance of setting the wage
level based on fairness and reasonability. Overall, these distinguished economists evaluated
Marshall’s idea of economic chivalry within the laissez-faire doctrine both positively and
negatively.
JEL classification numbers: A 13, B 13.参考文献:
（* 訳書を活用したが，必ずしも訳文に従っていない場合がある）
資 料
Marshall Papers, Section 5（ Marshall 5/11）, ケンブリッジ大学経済学部マーシャル図書館所蔵．
雑 誌
Cambridge Review 29（ 734）, June 1, 1908.［以下 CR と略記］
Cambridge Review 34（ 849）, February 6, 1913.
書 籍
Barbe, L. 2010. Francis Ysidro Edgeworth, translated by M. C. Black. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Burke, E［. 1790］ 1910. Reflections on the French Revolution & Other Essays. Everyman’s Library, No. 460. London and
Toronto: J. M. Dent and Sons. 半澤孝麿訳『フランス革命の省察』みすず書房，1978.
Creedy, J. 1981. F. Y. Edgeworth, 1845―1926. In Pioneers of Modern Economics in Britain, ed. by D. P. O’Brien and J. R.
Presley. London: Macmillan, 72―104.
Edgeworth, F. Y. 1881. Mathematical Psychics. London: C. Kegan Paul.
―. 1923. Women’s Wages in Relation to Economic Welfare. Economic Journal 33（ 132）: 487―95.
Fujii, K. 2009. Marshall on Economic Chivalry and Business Ethics. In Marshall and Schumpeter on Evolution, ed. by Y.
Shionoya and T. Nishizawa. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Gerbier, B. 2006. Economic Chivalry. In Elgar Companion to Alfred Marshall, ed. by T. Raffaelli, G. Beccattini, and M.
Dardi. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 532―35.
Groenewegen, P. 1995. Soaring Eagle. Brookfield: Edward Elgar.
Hobsbawm, E. J. 1968. Labouring Men: Studies in the History of Labour. Paperback ed. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
鈴木幹久・永井義雄訳『イギリス労働史研究』ミネルヴァ書房，1968.
Keynes, J. M［. 1925］ 2010. Am I a Liberal? In Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes, Vol. IX, Paperback ed. London:
Macmillan and Cambridge University Press, 295―306. 宮崎義一訳「私は自由党員か」『ケインズ全集 第
9 巻 説得論集』東洋経済新報社， 1981, 354―68.
―.［ 1926］ 2010. The End of Laissez-faire. In Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes, Vol. IX, Paperback ed.
London: Macmillan and Cambridge University Press, 272―94. 宮崎義一訳「自由放任の終焉」『ケインズ全
集 第9 巻 説得論集』，東洋経済新報社， 1981, 323―53.
―［. 1930］ 2010. Economic Possibilities for Our Grandchildren. In Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes, Vol.
IX, Paperback ed. London: Macmillan and Cambridge University Press, 321―32. 宮崎義一訳「わが孫たちの経
済的可能性」『ケインズ全集 第9 巻 説得論集』東洋経済新報社， 1981, 387―400.
―［. 1933］ 2010. Essays in Biography. In Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes, Vol. X, Paperback ed. London:
Macmillan and Cambridge University Press. 大野忠男訳『ケインズ全集 第10 巻 人物評伝』東洋経済新報社，
1981.
―［. 1936］ 2010. General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money. In Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes,
Vol. VII, Paperback ed. London: Macmillan and Cambridge University Press. 塩野谷祐一訳『ケインズ全集 第
7 巻 雇用，利子および貨幣の一般理論』東洋経済新報社， 1983.
McWilliams Tullberg, R. 1975. Marshall’s ‘Tendency to Socialism.’ History of Political Economy 7（ 1）: 75―111.
Marshall, A. 1881. Review of F. Y. Edgeworth’s Mathematical Psychics. Academy, June 18, 1881, 457.
―.［ 1884］ 1925. Where to House the London Poor. In Memorials of Alfred Marshall, ed. by A. C. Pigou. London:
Macmillan, 142―51. 永澤越郎訳「ロンドンの貧困者たちの居住をいかにすべきか」『マーシャル経済論文
集』岩波ブックセンター，1991, 286―97.
―.［ 1885］ 1925. The Present Position of Economics. In Memorials of Alfred Marshall, ed. by A. C. Pigou. London:
Macmillan, 152―74. 永澤越郎訳「経済学の現状」『マーシャル経済論文集』岩波ブックセンター， 1991, 1―
31.
―.［ 1887］ 1925. A Fair Rate of Wages. In Memorials of Alfred Marshall, ed. by A. C. Pigou. London: Macmillan,
212―26. 永澤越郎訳「公正な賃金率」『マーシャル経済論文集』岩波ブックセンター，1991, 257―75.
―［. 1893］ 1926. Preliminary Statement and Evidence before the Royal Commission on the Aged Poor（ 1893）. In Official
Papers by Alfred Marshall, ed. by J. M. Keynes. London: Macmillan, 197―262.
―. 1898. Distribution and Exchange. Economic Journal 8（ 29）: 35―59.
―［. 1907］ 1925. Social Possibilities of Economic Chivalry. In Memorials of Alfred Marshall, ed. by A. C. Pigou. London:
Macmillan, 323―46. 永澤越郎訳「経済騎士道の社会的可能性」『マーシャル経済論文集』岩波ブック
センター， 1991, 128―60.
―［. 1908］ 1926. Memorandum on Fiscal Policy of International Trade（ 1903）. In Official Papers by Alfred Marshall,
ed. by J. M. Keynes. London: Macmillan, 363―420. 服部正治・藤原新訳『国際貿易の財政政策に関する覚書
（1903 年）』上・中・下，『立教経済学研究』（立教大学）, 47（ 2）・47（ 3）・48（ 1）, 1993―1994.
―［. 1908］ 1993. Marshall’s Final Lecture, 21 May 1908, reproduced by R. McWilliams Tullberg. History of Political
Economy 25（ 4）: 605―16.
―. 1920. Principles of Economics, 8th ed. London: Macmillan. 永澤越郎訳『経済学原理』，四分冊，岩波ブック
センター信山社， 1985.
―. 1923. Industry and Trade, 4th ed. London: Macmillan. 永澤越郎訳『産業と商業』，三分冊，岩波ブックセン
ター信山社， 1986.
Matsuyama, N. 2011. The Source of Marshall’s Thoughts on Economic Progress with a Focus on his Study of American
Industry. In The 24th Conference of the History of Economic Thought Society of Australia. Royal Melbourne Institute
of Technology. July 2011.
Moggridge, D. E. 1993. Keynes, 3rd ed. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. 塩野谷祐一訳『ケインズ』東洋経済新
報社， 1979.
Pigou, A. C［. 1908］ 1999. Economic Science in Relation to Practice. In A. C. Pigou Collected Economic Writings, Vol. I,
ed. by D. Collard. London: Macmillan, 1―32. 本郷亮訳「実践との関わりにおける経済学」『ピグー 富と厚生』
名古屋大学出版会， 2012, 1―21.
―. 1912. Wealth and Welfare. London: Macmillan. 本郷亮訳『ピグー 富と厚生』名古屋大学出版会，2012, 23―
464.
―.［ 1913］ 1923. Employers and Economic Chivalry. In Essays in Applied Economics. London: P. S. King and Son,
12―23.
―. 1920. Economics of Welfare, 1st ed. London: Macmillan. 気賀健三他訳『厚生経済学』，四分冊，東洋経済新
報社， 1953.
Whitaker, J. K. 1975. Early Economic Writings of Alfred Marshall, 1867―1890, 2 vols. London: Macmillan.
―. 1990. What Happened to the Second Volume of the Principles?: The Thorny Path to Marshall’s Last Book. In Centenary
Essays on Alfred Marshall, ed. by J. K. Whitaker. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 193―222. 西
岡幹雄訳「『経済学原理』の第2 巻はどうなったのか？」『マーシャル経済学の体系』，橋本昭一監訳，
ミネルヴァ書房， 1997, 241―77.
―. 1996. Correspondences of Alfred Marshall. 3 vols. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
上宮智之．2013. 「 F. Y. エッジワースの男女賃金論」『経済学論究』（関西学院大学）67（ 2）: 101―24.
斧田好雄．1971. 「 マーシャルの経済騎士道について」『文化紀要』（弘前大学）（5）: 1―19.
桑原莞爾．1999. 『 イギリス関税改革運動の史的分析』九州大学出版会．
近藤真司．2002. 「 人間開発と教育投資」西岡幹雄・近藤真司著『ヴィクトリア時代の経済像―企業家・労働・
人間開発そして大学・教育拡充』萌書房，98―117.
柘植尚則．2014. 『 プレップ経済倫理学』弘文堂．
西沢 保．2007. 『 マーシャルと歴史学派の経済思想』岩波書店．
馬場啓之助．1961. 『 マーシャル』勁草書房．
早坂 忠．1976. 「 『マーシャル初期経済学論稿』」『HOPE ニューズレター』（1）: 11―16.
本郷 亮．2007. 『 ピグーの思想と経済学』名古屋大学出版会．
―. 2010. 「 ピグー『非自発的遊休の問題』（1910 年）―原文・邦訳・解説」『弘前学院大学 社会福祉学部研
究紀要』（10）: 62―78.
松山直樹．2014. 「 A. マーシャルにおける経済騎士道と公正賃金」『経済学史研究』55（ 2）: 54―72.
山本崇史．2009. 「 初期ピグーの保護関税批判と厚生経済学の三命題」『経済学史研究』50（ 2）: 56―73.
-
河野裕康 ヒルファディングの経済政策論と 1927 年農業綱領
75-95
-
Hilferding’s Economic Policy
and the 1927 Agrarian ProgramYuko Kawano
Abstract:
In the late 1920s, R. Hilferding （1877―1941）, an intellectual leader of the German Social
Democratic Party and prominent exponent of organised capitalism, played an important role
in economic policy, especially for agrarian problems. However, his activities have not been
completely explored from a historical point of view. In several international conferences in
1926, he argued against aggressive protectionism in favour of mutually beneficial trade
agreements and economic regulation under the League of Nations. Then, during parliamentary
discussions, he opposed the general rise of agrarian customs, and insisted on promoting
high-grade, intensified production by means of differentiated tariffs and financial aids. As for
international cartels, he led the 1927 inter-parliamentary commercial conference to accepting
his anti-monopolistic resolution.
Within the party, Hilferding, as commission chairperson, drafted an agrarian program
based on his own earlier ideas as well as on the Austrian program, and successfully persuaded
the party congress to adopt it in 1927. This program included measures for land reform,
productivity improvement, and social policy, among others, intending to cooperate with the
rural working populace anew.
As the financial situation worsened late in 1927 and the year after, he urged the temporary
introduction of foreign credits in order to maintain business prosperity. He criticised the
budget for mass taxation and military expenditure, highlighting the structural defects of the
fiscal transfer system, and tried to restore the balance through administrative reorganisation.
Nonetheless, he supported the emergency assistance project for agriculture, and demanded
individually granted loans as well as the control of commerce and even of production for stabilisation.
Overall, his economic policy aimed to make progresses in international cooperative
relationships, avoiding block economy, and cope with agrarian and financial difficulties
through productivity measures, basically grounded on his peculiar view of organised economy.
JEL classification numbers: B 24, B 31, P 16.参考文献:
Die Agrarier drohen mit Revolution. 25.1.1928. Vorwärts［ Vw］. Abend=Ausgabe［ AA］. Berlin.
Alles soll teuerer werden. 20.8.1926. Vw. AA.
Allgemeiner Kongreß der Arbeiter- und Soldatenräte Deutschlands. 1919. Berlin.（ Nachdruck［ ND］: 1972. Glashütten
im Taunus: Detlev Auvermann KG.）
Auftakt zur Weltwirtschaftstagung. 4.5.1927. Vw. Morgen=Ausgabe［ MA］.
Aufzeichnung über die Besprechungen mit den Parteiführern wegen der Getreidezölle. 26.11.1926. Bundesarchiv, Berlin
［BA. B］, Reichskanzlei, R43/I/1020.
Aushöhlung der Staatshoheit. 4.12.1927. Vw. MA.
Bachmann, U. 1996. Reichskasse und öffentlicher Kredit in der Weimarer Republik 1924―1932. Frankfurt/M.: Peter Lang.
Der Bauer soll enteignet werden! 20.4.1928［. ?］ Presse（. Hannover［ ?］.） BA. B, Reichslandbund［ RLB］, R8034 III, Nr.
196.
Becker, H. 1990. Handlungsspielräume der Agrarpolitik in der Weimarer Republik zwischen 1923 und 1929. Stuttgart:
Franz Steiner.
Beschlüsse der Luxemburger Konferenz. 22.11.1926. Vw. AA.
Böhret, C. 1966. Aktionen gegen die “kalte Sozialisierung.” Berlin: Duncker & Humblot.
Das Brot wirt noch teurer! 26.3.1927. Vw. AA.
Deutsche ausländische und internationale kartellverträge im Wortlaut. 1931. Eingeleitet von H. Wagenführ. Nürnberg:
Krische.
Deutsche Bundesbank ［DBb］, hrsg. 1976. Deutsche Geld- und Bankwesen in Zahlen 1876―1975. Frankfurt/M.: Fritz
Knapp.
Einfuhrscheine und Butterzoll. 14.9.1926. Vw. AA.
Der Eisenpakt vor dem Reichstag. 23.11.1926. Vw. AA.
Entwurf eines Agrarprogramms der Sozialdemokratischen Partei Deutschlands. 12.1.1927. Vw. MA.
Fabian, D. 1.4.1927. Der Kampf um die Seele des Bauern. Sozialistische Politik und Wirtschaft［ SPW］. Jg. 5, Nr. 13. Berlin.
Freie Weltwirtschaftskonferenz. 26.5.1926. Vw. MA.
Fünf Millionen für Wetterschäden. 28.7.1928. Vw. MA.
Gemeinsame Sitzung des Wirtschaftspolitischen und des Finanzpolitischen Ausschusses unter Hinzuziehung der Mitglieder
des Unterausschusses für Landwirtschaft und Ernährung. 13.7.1926. BA. B, Vorläufiger Reichswirtschaftsrat
［RWR］, R401/53966/403.
Genosse Hilferding schlägt sich selbst auf den Mund. 14.4.1928. Grüne Wochenschau, BA. B, RLB, R8034 III, Nr. 196.
Gerber, R. 1.7.1927. Das neue Agrarprogramm der deutschen Sozialdemokratie. Die Internationale. Jg. 10, H. 13. Berlin.
Die Gutsbezirke verschwinden! 13.12.1927. Vw. MA.
Handelskonferenz in Südamerika. 8.9.1927. Vw. AA.
Heller, F. 29.4.1927. Die Augen links. SPW. Jg. 5, Nr. 17.
Hilferding, R. 1927. Theoretische Bemerkungen zur Agrarfrage. Die Gesellschaft. IV, Bd. 1, H. 5. Berlin.（ ND: 1968.
Frankfurt/M.: Sauer & Auvermann.）
―. 1928 a. Die deutsche Wirtschaft und die internationale Verschuldung. Hamburger Überseejahrbuch. Bd. 5. Hamburg.
―. 1928 b. Prof. Adolf Weber, Hat Schacht recht? Die Gesellschaft. V, Bd. 1, H. 2.
Internationale Handelspolitik. 1.3.1926. Vw. AA.
Die interparlamentarische Wirtschaftskonferenz. 26.5.1926. Frankfurter Zeitung und Handelsblatt. Abendblatt.
Die Kabinette Marx III und IV. 1988. 2 Bde. Bearb. von G. Abramowski. Boppard/Rh.: Harald Boldt.
Kalte Sozialisierung? 31.3.1926. Vw. MA.
Kampf um das Notprogramm. 20.4.1928. Vw. MA.
Kohlenwirtschaft und Schiffahrt. 27.5.1926. Vw. MA.
Konjunktur-Statistisches Handbuch. 1933. Hrsg. vom Institut für Konjunkturforschung. Berlin: Reimar Hobbing.
Kretzen, J. 15.4.1927. Zur Entwicklung der Landwirtschaft in Deutschland. SPW. Jg. 5, Nr. 15.
Krüger, H. und F. Baade. o. J［. 1927?］. Sozialdemokratische Agrarpolitik. Berlin: J. H. W. Dietz Nachf.
League of Nations. 1927. Report and Proceedings of the World Economic Conference. Geneva.
Mehr Macht der Sozialdemokratie! 12.4.1928. Vw. MA.
Milliarden für Agrarier. 27.1.1928. Vw. MA.
Die Millionen für die Landwirtschaft. 21.3.1928. Vw. MA.
Müller, Helmut. 1973. Die Zentralbank. Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag.
Neue Wege der Gasfernversorgung? 14.9.1927. Vw. MA.
Neuer Bürgerblockanschlag. 26.3.1927. Vw. MA
Ein neues Zollattentat. 2.7.1926. Vw. AA.
Pahl, W. 8.3.1926. Staatssozialismus. Sozialistische Monatshefte. Jg. 32, Bd. 63, H. 3. Berlin.
Protokoll des sozialdemokratischen Parteitages［ ProtSdPt］［. SPÖ］. 1925. Wien.
Protokoll über die Verhandlungen des Parteitages der sozialdemokratischen Partei Deutschlands［ ProtVPtSPD］. 1891,
1894, 1895. Berlin（. ND: 1978. Berlin und Bonn: J. H. W. Dietz Nachf.）
Reichsgesetzblatt［ RGBI］. Jg. 1902, 1923, 1925―1928. Berlin.
Respondek, E. 1929. Wirtschaftliche Zusammenarbeit zwischen Deutschland und Frankreich. Berlin: Carl Heymanns.
Schacht, H. 1927 a. Eigene oder geborgte Währung. Leipzig: Quelle & Meyer.
―. 1927 b. Die Stabilisierung der Mark. Berlin und Leipzig: Deutsche Verlags-Anstalt.
Schieles Vollmachten beschnitten. 29.4.1928. Vw. MA.
Schluß der Wirtschaftskonferenz. 28.5.1926. Vw. AA.
Der Schutz der landwirtschaftlichen Erzeugung als Vorbedingung des Wiederaufbaues der deutschen Wirtschaft:
Denkschrift zur 55. Vollversammlung des Deutschen Landwirtschaftsrates. 1925. Berlin.
Sering, M. 1932. Die deutsche Landwirtschaft unter volks- und weltwirtschaftlichen Gesichtspunkten. Berlin: Paul Parey.
Sitzung des Ausschusses für den Reichshaushalt ［SARh］. BA. B, Reichstag, R101/31145/1481, 1927; R101/31146/
1483―1484, 1928.
Sitzung des Wirtschaftspolitischen Ausschusses［ SWpA］. 22.9.1925. BA. B, RWR, R401/53966/402.
So geht es nicht, Herr Schiele! 1.4.1928. Vw. MA.
Sozialdemokratische Agrarpolitik. 20.1.1928. Vw. MA.
Sozialdemokratischer Parteitag［ SdPt］.［ SPD］. 1924, 1925. Berlin; 1927. Kiel.（ ND: 1974. Glashütten im Taunus:
Detlev Auvermann.）
Sozialistische Zollkonferenz in Paris. 16.10.1927. Vw. Sonntagsausgabe.
Statistisches Bundesamt［ StBa］, hrsg. 1972. Bevölkerung und Wirtschaft 1872―1972. Stuttgart und Mainz: W. Kohlhammer.
Statistisches Reichsamt ［StRa］, bearb. 1930 a. Die deutsche Finanzwirtschaft vor und nach dem Kriege. Berlin: Reimar
Hobbing.
―, bearb. 1930 b. Finanz und Steuern im In- und Ausland. Berlin: Reimar Hobbing.
―, hrsg. Statistisches Jahrbuch für das Deutsche Reich. Jg. 51, 1932; Jg. 53, 1934. Berlin.
―, bearb. 1937. Verbrauch und Einkommen in der Steuerwirtschaft. Berlin.
Stegmann, D. 1974. Deutsche Zoll- und Handelspolitik 1924/5―1929 unter besonderer Berücksichtigung agrarischer und
industrieller Interessen. In Industrielles System und politische Entwicklung in der Weimarer Republik. Hrsg. von H.
Mommsen, D. Petzina, und B. Weisbrot. Düsseldorf: Droste.
Stresemann, G. 1933. Vermächtnis. Bd. 3. Berlin: Ullstein.
Subventiönchen statt Subvention. 28.4.1928. Vw. MA.
Südslawienvertrag und Maiszoll. 8.12.1927. Vw. MA.
Suhr, O. 20.8.1927. Die organisierte Wirtschaft. Vw. MA.
Treiber, H. 1929. Die Beurteilung der Getreide-Einfuhrscheine in Deutschland. Diss. Erlangen.
La XIIIème assemblée plénière de la Conférence parlementaire internationale du commerce de Rio-de-Janeiro（ le 5 sept.
1927）. Rapport par E. Labarthe.［ 1927］. Archives du Ministère des Affaires Étrangères, Paris, Relations commerciales
1920―1940, B 29, 2, Conférence parlementaire internationale 1920―32 et 1937―1939.
Ursachen und Folgen. o. J. Bd. 6. Berlin.
Verhandlungen des Reichstags［ VRt］. Bd. 377, Bd. 382, 1924; Bd. 390, 1926; Bd. 393, 1927; Bd. 394―95, 1928; Bd. 407―
09, 1926; Bd. 413, Bd. 415―17, 1927; Bd. 422, 1928; Bd. 423, 1929. Berlin（. ND: 1986. Bad Feilnbach: Schmidt Periodicals.）
Wandel, E. 1971. Die Bedeutung der Vereinigten Staaten von Amerika für das deutsche Reparationsproblem 1924―1929.
Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr.
Weber, A. 1928. Hat Schacht recht? München und Leipzig: Duncker & Humblot.
Weber, W. 1932. Chronik der deutschen Agrarpolitik 1914―1932. In Deutsche Agrarpolitik. Teil 2. Hrsg. von F. Beckmann,
B. Harms, T. Brinkmann, et al. Berlin: Reimar Hobbing.
Weltwirtschaft und Zollpolitik. 30.6.1927. Vw. AA.
Der Widersinn der Wucherzölle. 7.7.1927. Vw. AA.
Winkler, H. A. 1988. Der Schein der Normalität. 2.Aufl. Berlin und Bonn: J. H. W. Dietz Nachf.
上田貞次郎編．1927.『国際経済会議と其問題』同文舘．
海野文雄．1972.「ワイマール期における農業問題」『社会経済史学』38（ 3）.
大矢繁夫．1981.「相対的安定期におけるドイツの外資依存」『研究年報経済学』（東北大学）43（ 1）.
河野裕康．1993.『ヒルファディングの経済政策思想』法政大学出版局．
―. 2009.「ヒルファディングの外交及び通商政策論とハイデルベルク綱領」『西洋史学』232.
―. 2015.「ヴァイマル中期のヒルファディングの連立政策論と社会経済思想」『社会思想史研究』39.
栗原藤七郎．1928.「独逸社会民主党と農業問題」『社会政策時報』93.
豊永泰子．1994.『ドイツ農村におけるナチズムへの道』ミネルヴァ書房．
原田 溥．1987.『ドイツ社会民主党と農業問題』九州大学出版会．
古内博行．1980.「ワイマル期ドイツ農業の危機と農業政策」『社会経済史学』46（ 2）.
-
塩見由梨 ジェイムズ・ステュアートの商業論
96-117
-
Sir James Steuart’s Theory of Commerce
Yuri Shiomi
Abstract:
This article aims to realise the concept of commerce on market economy in Sir James
Steuart’s An Inquiry into the Principles of Political Economy.
Studies concerning the social function of commerce remain limited, whereas commerce
has performed an essential role for the functioning of the market. Sir James Steuart, known as
a mercantilist, focused on importance of commercial activities and theorised on it in early
times. I shall read his theory and offer an explanation of the idea and function of commerce
in it.
According to Steuart’s Inquiry, Book II, the main concept of commerce is not an intermediary
role between producers and consumers but a trade among merchants. Merchants’ behavioural
principle is rational, unlike the limited rationality of producers and consumers.
Trade among merchants creates the proper market price through the operation of ‘double
competition’ and provides market information to non-merchants, producers or consumers, by
the market price determined by it. Moreover, through the emergence the current prices in
trade, commerce promotes the use of money in consumers’ hands.
Steuart’s theory of commerce provides an explanation of the reason for the necessity of
merchants and commerce in market economy. His theory of the principle of commerce
should be considered as an effective economic theory focusing on the significance of commerce
in modern economy.
JEL classification numbers: B 11, B 31, D 49.
Sir James Steuart’s Theory of Commerce
Yuri Shiomi参考文献:
Anderson, G. M. and R. D. Tollison. 1984. Sir James Steuart as the Apotheosis of Mercantilism and His Relation to Adam
Smith. Southern Economic Journal 51（ 1）: 456―68.
Augier, Laurent and Christine Théré. 1999. James Steuart’s Approach to Stability of Price and Economic Policy: The Example
of Grain Prices. In The Economics of James Steuart, ed. by Ramón Tortajada. London: Routledge, 151―68.
Hutchison, T. W. 1988. Before Adam Smith: The Emergence of Political Economy, 1662―1776. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Sen, Samar R. 1957. The Economics of Sir James Steuart. London; G. Bell and Sons.
Smith, Adam. 1776. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations. London. Ed. by R. H. Campbell and
A. S. Skinner. Oxford: Clarendon Press. 大河内一男監訳『国富論』全3 分冊，中公文庫．1978.
Steuart, J［. 1805］ 1998. An Inquiry into the Principles of Political Oeconomy. In The Works, Political, Metaphysical, and
Chronological, of the late Sir James Steuart of Coltness, Bart. Now First collected by General Sir James Steuart,
Bart., 6 vols., London. Ed. By A. S. Skinner and N. Kobayashi, 4 vols. London: Pickering and Chatto. 小林昇監訳
『経済の原理』全2 分冊．名古屋大学出版会，1993―1998.
Yang, Hong-Seok. 1994. The Political Economy of Trade and Growth: An Analytical Interpretation of Sir James Steuart’s
Inquiry. Aldershot: Edward Elgar.
大友敏明．1987. 「 ステュアート『原理』における経済循環の把握について」『三田学会雑誌』80（ 3）: 49―74.
―. 1997. 「 ジェイムズ・ステュアート研究の現段階」経済学史学会『年報』35: 106―13.
大森郁夫．1996. 『 ステュアートとスミス』ミネルヴァ書房．
川島信義．1972. 『 ステュアート研究―重商主義の社会・経済思想』未来社．
小林 昇．1977 a. 『 小林昇経済学史著作集 IV イギリス重商主義研究（2）』未来社．
―. 1977 b. 『 小林昇経済学史著作集 V J.ステュアート研究』未来社．
―. 1977 c. 『 増補 国富論体系の成立』未来社．
竹本 洋．1995. 『 経済学体系の創生―ジェイムズ・ステュアート研究』名古屋大学出版会．
田添京二．1990. 『 サー・ジェイムズ・ステュアートの経済学』八朔社．
平瀬巳之吉．1954. 『 経済学の古典と近代』時潮社．
水田 健．2002. 「 アダム・スミスの「自然的自由の制度」と重商主義」竹本洋・大森郁夫編『重商主義再考』
日本経済評論社，127―53.
-
English Translation Series: Japanese Historians of Economic Thought〈5〉
Takuya Hatori, Early Period Ricardo’s Theories of Value and Distribution Translated by Robert Chapeskie and Shigeyoshi Senga118-161
Notes and Communications
-
参考文献:
Pasinetti, L. L. 1973. The Notion of Vertical Integration in Economic Analysis. Metroeconomica 25（ 1）: 1―29. 中野守・
宇野立身訳『生産と分配の理論―スラッファ理論の新展開』日本経済評論社，1998, 第2 章．
柴田 敬．1953 a. 『 資本主義世界経済論・上―経済学は「逆立ち」している』三和書房．
―. 1953 b.「 生産部門の間の正常的比例（ I） ―経済学は「逆立ち」している」『山口経済学雑誌』4（ 1.2）: 1―
17.
柴田 敬・新田政則．1970. 『 近代経済学原理』ミネルヴァ書房．
西 淳．2013. 「 自己回帰的生産構造における平均生産期間の規定問題―柴田敬の試みと松尾匡による定式化
との関係」『季刊 経済理論』50（ 2）: 69―76.
―. 2014. 「 柴田敬によるベーム―バヴェルク理論の一般化の試み―生産構造の問題を中心として」『経済学
史研究』56（ 1）: 48―70.
―. 2015. 「 ベーム – バヴェルク型経済とマルクス型経済との関係について」『立命館経済学』64（ 2）: 84―90.
―. 2016. 「 ベーム＝柴田モデルと拡大再生産」『季刊 経済理論』53（ 2）: 87―93.
-
Maria Cristina Marcuzzo, Following in Shionoya's Footsteps. Perfectionism and in Keynes’s Political Philosophy
168-180
-
参考文献:
Backhouse, R. E. and B. W. Bateman. 2006. John Maynard Keynes: Artist, Philosopher, Economist.
Atlantic Economic Journal 34（ 2）: 149-59.
Bateman, B. 2006. Keynes and Keynesianism. In The Cambridge Companion to Keynes, ed.
by R. E. Backhouse and B. W. Bateman. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 258-
71.
Brittan, S. 2006. Keynes’s Political Philosophy. In The Cambridge Companion to Keynes, ed.
by R. E. Backhouse and B. W. Bateman. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: 180-
98.
Carabelli, A. and N. De Vecchi. 1999. Where to Draw the Line’? Keynes versus Hayek on
Knowledge, Ethics and Economics. Journal of the History of Economic Thought 6（ 2）:
271-96.
Cox, J. 1995. Keynes: An Archivist View in New Perspectives on Keynes, ed. by A. F. Cottrell
and M. S. Lawlor. History of Political Economy Annual Supplement, 163-75.
Cristiano, C. and M. C. Marcuzzo. 2018. John Maynard Keyes: The Economist as Investor.
Review of Keynesian Economics 6（ 2）（ forthcoming）.
Donnini Macciò, D. 2015. The Apostles’ Justice: Cambridge Reflections on Economic Inequality
from Moore’s Principia Ethica to Keynes’s General Theory（ 1903-36）. Cambridge
Journal of Economics 4（ 3）: 701-26.
Fantacci, L., M. C. Marcuzzo, A. Rosselli, and E. Sanfilippo. 2012. Speculation and Buffer
Stocks: The Legacy of Keynes and Kahn. European Journal for the History of Economic
Thought 19（ 3）: 453-73.
Habermas, J. 1995. Reconciliation Through the Public Use of Reason: Remarks on John
Rawls’s Political Liberalism. Journal of Philosophy 92（ 3）: 109-31.
Hamada, Y. 1986. The Impact of the General Theory in Japan. Eastern Economic Journal XII
（4）: 451-66.
Keynes, J. M. 1971-89. The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes（ CWK）, ed. by E.
Johnson and D. E. Moggridge. London: Macmillan.
CWK VII, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money
CWK IX. Essays in Persuasion
CWK XIX, Activities 1922-29: The Return to Gold and Industrial Policy
CWK XXIV, Activities 1944-46: The Transition to Peace
CWK XXV, Activities 1940-44: Shaping the Post-War World: The Cleaning Union
CWK XXVII, Activities 1940-46: Shaping the Post-War World: Employment and Commodities
Marcuzzo, M. C. 2006. Keynes and Cambridge. In The Cambridge Companion to Keynes, ed.
by R. E. Backhouse and B. W. Bateman. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 118-
35.
–. 2008. Keynes and Persuasion. In Keynes for the Twenty-First Century: The Continuing
Relevance of The General Theory, ed. by M. Forstater and L. R. Wray. London: Palgrave
Macmillan, 23-40.
–. 2010 a. Whose Welfare State? Beveridge vs Keynes. In No Wealth but Life: Welfare
Economics and the Welfare State in Britain 1880-1945, ed. by R. E. Backhouse and T.
Nishizawa. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 189-206.
–. 2010 b. Reason and Reasonableness in Keynes. Rereading The Economic Consequences
of the Peace in Perspectives on Keynesian Economics, edited by A. Arnon, J. Weinblatt,
and W. Young. Heidelberg: Springer, 35-52.
O’Donnell, R. 1989. Keynes: Philosophy, Economics and Politics. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Pettit, P. 2002. Non-consequentialism and Political Philosophy. In Robert Nozick, ed. by D.
Schmidt. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 83-104.
Rawls, J. 1993. Political Liberalism. The John Dewey Essays in Philosophy, Vol. 4. New York:
Columbia University Press.
Shionoya, Y. 1991. Sidgwick, Moore and Keynes: A Philosophical Analysis of Keynes’s ‘My
Early Beliefs.’ In Keynes and Philosophy: Essays on the Origin of Keynes’s Thought, ed.
by B. W. Bateman and J. B. Davis. Aldershot: Edward Elgar, 6-29.
–. 2005. Economy and Morality. The Philosophy of the Welfare State. Aldershot: Edward
Elgar.
Skidelsky, R. 1988. Keynes’s Political Legacy. In Keynes and Public Policy after Fifty Years,
vol. 1, Economics and Politics, ed. by O. F. Hamouda and J. N. Smithin. Aldershot: Edward
Elgar, 3-28.
–. 2000. John Maynard Keynes, vol. III: Fighting for Britain, 1937-1946. London: Macmillan.
–. 2009. Keynes: The Return of the Master. New York: Public Affairs.
書評
西本和見
加藤 健
-
Thomas C. Leonard, Illiberal Reformers: Race, Eugenics, and American Economics in the Progressive Era, Princeton University Press, 2016